Search This Blog

Sunday, 30 October 2011

Structure in the MLS

2007 marked the year in which the MLS could begin to gear towards worldwide audience. It was of course the July signing of David Beckham by League giants L.A that surprised and shocked many, in a deal worth an estimated $32 million towards Beckham's personal wealth, and hundred of millions in revenue. Shirt sales at Galaxy hit astronomical figures and the MLS found itself growing in popularity by the minute. Thierry Henry joined New York in 2010, and Robbie Keane bolstered the LA attack in 2011, which already included Landon Donovan, the USA's prodigal son. Add the these big name signings the States' superb World Cup campaign in 2010, and it's easy to see why 'soccer' is a sport on the rise. 

The MLS as a league will celebrate it's 20th birthday in 2013, and it could be a completely different league by that time. The League will expand from 18 teams to 19 teams with the introduction of Montreal Impact in 2012, and shortly after, team #20 will be added.

This is where the Major Soccer League could face a problem.

FIFA guidelines state that a top league should not exceed 20 teams, but there is clearly no intention to stop at 20. North America has a population of 530 million, and Europe has a population of 720 million, two not vastly different figures in terms of world population, would it be fair for Europe to have 1 top league limited to 20 teams? Of course not. Whilst it would be fascinating in a form of an ultimate Champions League, all the games character would vanish, all local pride. You're local derby would be against a team two countries over. Ridiculous. 

The MLS has options. Expand until there are simply too many teams in a single league. Multiple none changing leagues, with no promotions or relegations. Or, a tiered format, with promotion and relegation including the introduction of MLS 2.

Most fans of the game in the States and Canada are firmly in favour of promotion and relegation. Rumour has it that when the league hits 24 teams, then there will be a split, with the top league having 14 teams and the bottom league having 10 teams with promotion and relegation. Most football fans in the world will tell you this is the greatest part of league football, the most passionate and fascinating. The excitement of playing at a higher level infront of a global audience, against better teams and bigger crowds is everything.

This is the only option if football is hoping to become a huge sport state side.

The proposal of course has its stumbling blocks. A franchise now could cost team 20 up to $70 million. It's unlikely an owner will pay this much to be told their team will be playing second tier football. This is a prime issue MLS commissioner Don Garber must address if he wants his league to grow correctly.

Sir Alex Ferguson believes that the USA could have 4 separate leagues. "The possibilities are endless for the US" he was quoted saying during Manchester United's pre season tour. With the size of the place to take into account, it might be a possibility, with a huge play off campaign come the end of the season, similar of course to the NFL.

The tried and tested formation of competitive football is a pro/rel campaign. If The United States of America is confident of being successful, recognised and respected in the football world, then the sooner is splits in two, the better.

No comments:

Post a Comment